How to Choose a School Mascot: Selection Guide + 100 Ideas

Related: Complete Mascot Design Guide | Mascot Design Psychology | Mascot Logo Design

Choosing a school mascot feels like it should be simple. Pick an animal, draw it, put it on things. In practice, it’s one of the most consequential branding decisions a school makes, and the process determines whether the mascot gets adopted with pride or sits on a shelf.

The “safe” trap

Committees gravitate toward safe choices: generic wildcats, standard eagles, cartoonish bears that look like clip art. Safe is forgettable. In a crowded market, your mascot is a key differentiator. If it looks like every other school in the county, you’ve missed the opportunity entirely.

Look for unique angles: local history, regional wildlife, specific values or traditions tied to your community. A mascot that could only belong to your school is worth ten times more than one shared by 6 other schools in the area.

The 6-step selection process

1. Form a selection committee. Diverse representation: students, faculty, parents, alumni. Different perspectives ensure the mascot appeals broadly and respects the community’s values. But use the committee for input, not design decisions. Design by committee produces bland results.

2. Define what the mascot should represent. Before brainstorming animals, define values. What traits should the mascot embody? Courage, resilience, intelligence, community? Does the school have a unique history or tradition the mascot could reflect? This is the brief that drives everything else.

3. Brainstorm concepts, not designs. Don’t start drawing. People get attached to bad art or dismiss good ideas because of a weak sketch. Keep this stage focused on concepts and stories. Does “The Voyagers” tell a better story than “The Tigers”? Focus on narrative first. Mascot design psychology research should inform this stage.

4. Survey the community. Once you have a shortlist, get broader input. Conduct a survey where people can vote and provide feedback. This isn’t a binding election (that leads to lowest-common-denominator choices), but it provides valuable data on community perception and catches problems early.

5. Review feedback and decide. The committee considers survey results alongside the strategic criteria defined in step 2. The final decision should weigh community preference, uniqueness in the region, visual versatility, and alignment with school values.

6. Design and unveil professionally. This is where most schools stumble. They hand the concept to a student contest or a local volunteer. A mascot needs to work on a gym floor, an embroidered shirt, a social media avatar, and a 7-foot costume. Amateur designs don’t scale. Work with a professional mascot designer and plan a reveal event that turns the launch into a community moment.

After the launch

The mascot needs ongoing attention to stay relevant. The costume needs maintenance and proper care. Spirit wear designs should refresh periodically to maintain student interest. The mascot should appear consistently at events, not just homecoming. Brand guidelines should cover how the mascot is used so it doesn’t fragment across departments.

If the mascot starts feeling dated, a redesign checklist helps evaluate whether you need a refresh (modernize the illustration while keeping the character) or something more. Most schools need the former, not a complete mascot change.

A mascot chosen through a thoughtful process, designed professionally, and maintained consistently becomes the symbol that ties everything together: student belonging, family advocacy, community pride, and enrollment growth.

---

Where to start

• Explore mascot design services
• Read the complete mascot design guide
• See mascot projects in our portfolio
• Talk to us